One 16 oz package of Oreo
5 cups Large Marshmallows
4 tablespoons butter
Place Oreos in the food processor/blender/magic bullet until they're ground up.
RP Servings: 16 or so.
Stars: 1. It was actually inedible. It was hard as a rock, and when I was finally able to break apart a tiny smidgen to try it (the things I do for you people), it got stuck in my teeth the entire rest of the night until I vigorously brushed and flossed. (Yes, I also flossed because of you. FLOSSED.)
I can tell you the exact step where it went wrong- it was in the microwave. The original blog stated 1.5-2 minutes in the microwave. My microwave has way less wattage than most microwaves, so I did 2 minutes, which would be a bit less than 1.5 minutes in regular microwaves. You can see it slightly, but basically where the butter touched the bottoms of the marshmallows, it got burned. Which then threw the whole consistency off. I couldn't even stir all the cookies into the marshmallow, and I knew instantly it went wrong. With great hesitancy I would try it again, probably only microwaving 30 seconds at a time.